• Home
  • Mobility Perspectives
  • CoMotion LIVE Webinars
  • Podcast
  • Whitepapers
  • Home
  • Mobility Perspectives
  • CoMotion LIVE Webinars
  • Podcast
  • Whitepapers
Home » Mobility-as-a-Service Policy Top News

California Agency Rules Uber and Lyft Drivers Are Employees, Not Freelancers

Jim Manning Posted On June 11, 2020
0
2.1K Views
0


0
Shares
  • Share On Facebook
  • Tweet It

The ongoing saga continues: the Golden State struck a powerful blow in the fight that’s pitted TNCs like Uber and Lyft against California Assembly Bill 5. The battle over AB5 stems from the rideshare giants’ classification of their drivers as 1099 freelancers, instead of regular W2 employees. On Tuesday June 9th, the California Public Utilities Commission officially ruled that “a person providing labor or services for remuneration shall be considered an employee rather than an independent contractor.” Lawsuits have been lobbed back and forth by both the state and the ridesharing companies, so while California’s recent ruling sounds definitive, don’t expect the fight to end here.

Uber had already filed a lawsuit in federal court that sought to keep its drivers classified as independent contractors, while both Uber and Lyft were also able to get a measure on the November 2020 ballot in California. If passed, that measure would exclude all app-based drivers from AB5’s new employee-qualification criteria. Regardless of those initiatives, the CPUC still has authority over the TNCs, meaning that for now, the companies will have to comply with the new order. The regulatory agency warned the rideshare providers that they must provide workers’ compensation to their employees by July 1st, or else risk losing their operating licenses.

TNC drivers are presumed to be employees and the commission must ensure that TNCs comply with those requirements that are applicable to the employees of an entity subject to the commission’s jurisdiction.

Uber spokesperson Davis White states the company’s case as “if California regulators force rideshare companies to change their business model it would affect our ability to provide reliable and affordable services, along with threatening access to this essential work Californians depend on.” In plain English, AB5 would seriously hurt its bottom line. If, after the dust from all the lawsuits settles, AB5 is to be enforced, all California rideshare employees would need to be paid minimum wage, and not just going forward: drivers would be owed back pay since the implementation of AB5 on January 1st, 2020.

While AB5 is only a California state law, it could be the start of a larger trend. Three other states are already following the Golden State’s lead, with legislators in New York, New Jersey, and Illinois considering similar bills that would materially benefit freelance workers. These bills aren’t aimed solely at TNCs, as construction workers, janitors, truckers and others would reap the rewards as well. It’s just in rideshare companies’ best interests to fight against any increased costs, seeing as the industry is yet to turn a profit.

For now, it looks as though California has the upper hand. Genevieve Shiroma, a commissioner with the California Public Utilities Commission said, “TNC drivers are presumed to be employees and the commission must ensure that TNCs comply with those requirements that are applicable to the employees of an entity subject to the commission’s jurisdiction.” With the state’s payment deadline fast approaching on July 1st, Uber and Lyft will be forced to make another major decision regarding compliance; expect this battle to rage on at least through the November election.

Post Views: 2,063
0
Shares
  • Share On Facebook
  • Tweet It


ab5californiaCPUClyftridersharingtncuber


Author

Jim Manning

Jim has written for ETHNews, Next Reality, 1stSlice and many more. Contact him at jmanning@comotionglobal.com

Trending Now
Week in Review: Are we getting the EVs we deserve?
Jack Craver January 9, 2023
CoMotion LIVE 01/25 - Can lower density cities join the bike revolution?
Contributor January 18, 2023
You may also like
Week in Review: America has a new #2 EV maker
December 5, 2022
Week in Review: Lyft layoffs, driverless rides to the airport & CoMotion LA next week!
November 7, 2022
Week in Review: A troubling climate report & mixed signals on AVs
October 31, 2022
Battered by Coronavirus, Micromobility May Have Route to Revival
Read Next

Battered by Coronavirus, Micromobility May Have Route to Revival

  • - Advertisement -
    “"
  • Subscribe

    Stay on the cutting edge of new mobility!
    Sign up for CoMotion NEWS

  • Popular Posts

    • 1
      Week in Review: Can Tesla make money with low prices?
  • Categories

    • CoMotion LIVE & CoMotion IMPACT Webinars
      50
    • Editor's Choice
      15
    • Future Mobility
      15
    • Green Vehicles
      7
    • Micromobility
      16
    • Mobility-as-a-Service
      22
    • Perspectives
      27
    • Policy
      23
    • Press Release
      2
    • Public Transit
      27
    • Smart Cities
      8
    • Top News
      229
    • Videos
      34
    • Whitepapers
      2


Stay Updated

Stay on the cutting edge of new mobility!
Sign up for CoMotion NEWS

  • - Advertisement -

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
© CoMotion Inc │ Powering a Sustainable Multimodal Future for All
Press enter/return to begin your search